State Farm® Insurance Agent Mike McNicholas
Leave Us a Review
Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.
Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.
What our customers say about us...
Angela Stassi
February 10, 2026
"Cindy was extremely helpful in assisting my husband and myself on the State Farm app. I walked into the office and she stopped everything and helped. She answered all of my questions and was very thorough in explaining the process."
Duane Pulliam
February 7, 2026
"Our online premium payment was erroneously sent to the wrong account unknowingly to us. When we received a notification of non-payment we contacted Cindy at the agency and asked her to inquire about the situation. Thankfully, with Cindy's help, we were able to rectify the error and get our payment applied to the correct account and avoid a policy cancelation. Many thanks to Cindy and the agency for taking care of the issue."
"I know this caused alot of worry....So glad we could get this taken care of !"
Taryn Hobbs
February 2, 2026
"Cindy was a tremendous help! Always professional and very knowledgeable! I would recommend this office to anyone!!"
"Thanks Taryn! We love the great feedback and appreciate your business : )"
Vickie Fitzgerald
January 23, 2026
"They have been extremely helpful and I am paying lower premiums than I was prior! I like that they answer my questions quickly and politely."
"Glad we could help your budget!"
Elizabeth Hale
January 7, 2026
"Insurance can be frustrating by itself. I landed in State Farms lap moving back from out of state bout 3yrs ago. They happened to be my best rate as it was, but when I've needed to contact them with questions (and Ive had them! Lol)it's definitely been painless. Having a live, local person & various options for contacting is huge when you need to understand things to make the right choices. Cindy is very personable, patient & thorough which are pretty important with all the different changes we have going on each year. Great service from a local office!"
"Thanks Elizabeth! Glad we could get your questions answered : ) we are appreciate your business"
Kim Van nevel
December 30, 2025
"Friendly and efficient service!"
"Thank you so much! Brett has alot of experience, so glad he could help"
Baylin Dunn
December 16, 2025
"Brett helped me save $100 a month making the switch on my auto insurance. Great service, and super friendly."
"Welcome to our agency!!"
Rene Rodems
December 5, 2025
"Brett is super nice and answered every question I had.I am happy to be in the State Farm family. Thanks Brett. Rene'"
"Thanks Rene, we are grateful for your trust : )"
Brandon Bushnell
November 26, 2025
"I have been insured by Mike's office for years now. On Wednesday, May 1st, 2019, our basement flooded due to the drains backing up. I was able to talk directly with Mike about the claim, and he guided us through the process. On top of that, our adjusters, both the inside and field adjuster, were incredibly kind and helpful!! We had a service company out to inspect the damage on Thursday, May 2nd. Even with this date being classified as a "catastrophe" due to the number of claims, we were able to have the field adjuster out by Sunday, May 5th. They had THOUSANDS of claims, but were able to bring in State Farm adjusters from all over the country to help make sure people didn't have to wait. Our adjuster came all the way from Florida! While there, the adjuster went through everything in detail. He gave us a detailed list of all work that would need done, an exact draft of the entire basement, and provided us with the total insurance payment we would receive. We are expecting the check today. We could not be more thrilled with how well this claim was handled! I would also like to send a big thanks to my Agent, Mike, and his team! #statefarmforlife"
"Its always so good to see you wish it was under better circumstances!. So glad your claim worked out so well. I am so grateful for your trust in me and my office over the years."
Beth N
November 25, 2025
"I recently purchased a new car. Mike McNicholas and team made the transaction easy. Zach answered all of my questions and Brett helped me set up my State Farm app. My experience with Mike’s team has always been positive."
"Thanks Beth!! Zach and Brett really try hard to help our customers. Thanks for letting us know. Enjoy your new ride!"
Jennifer Burk
November 21, 2025
"Called the office about a payment mishap and Cindy was amazing and got it done amazing quick. Thank you so much!!"
"Awesome!! Thanks Jennifer...So glad we could help!"
Jo Ann Aldrich
November 21, 2025
"I am very happy with my agent Brett. Very professional."
"thanks Jo Ann!! So glad we could be helpful!"
Angela Crawford
November 6, 2025
"We got a new car insurance policy and Cindy helped us get it added quickly and made it really easy process for us over the phone. Much appreciated thank you Cindy!"
"Thanks Angie!! We appreciate your trust in us!"
Joesph Coffey
October 28, 2025
"Cindy was fabulous in helping me set up a paperless account. The State Farm set up number doesn't let you talk to anyone and was very confusing at best and basically sucked. Cindy saved me!!!!"
"Thanks so much. The online stuff can be so frustrating, so glad we could help get the issue resolved and get you back up and running : ) "
William Reim
October 7, 2025
"Thank you brett, very helpful, and great service"
Vishnu Gokul Krishnamoorthy
October 6, 2025
"Had a very good experience with Brett Callarman for the first time in person for Auto insurance bundling along with renters. He clearly explained and got the best rates for me and my girlfriend. Definitely way better deal for my Tesla. Would highly recommend to get Auto insurance here if you are in Springfield."
"Thank you Vishnu! We are glad to help explain things and put some electricity in your insurance policy!!"
Emily Krall
October 4, 2025
"We had a guy with glasses help us. Sorry we forgot your name. He was great!"
"Thank you so much. Corrective eyesight is a staple in our office. Thank you for the kind words!!"
Cathy Thomas
October 2, 2025
"I called to ask about a claim. Cindy was very helpful. She took the time to explain the whole process and what my various options were. I believe we were on this phone for probably 20 minutes. She didn't rush me. She explained everything. You've got a good Employee. Hang onto her!!"
"thanks Cathy! We appreciate your business"
Granny
October 2, 2025
"Very nice and easy to set my insurance. Didn't take no time at all."
"thanks Granny!!"
Crystal B
September 26, 2025
"I always have a great experience working with Cindy at State Farm! She is knowledgeable, friendly, and extremely helpful. It's rare to find someone who combines professionalism with genuine care for me, and I truly appreciate her support. Highly recommend Cindy!"
"Crystal-Thank you for letting us be your "good neighbor" over the years : ) "
Tulin Ozyurt
September 25, 2025
"Mike McNicholas and his team at State Farm are great to work with. Brett was a huge help with changing car policies. Thank you!"
Mitchel Smith
September 18, 2025
"Brett was very informative and did an amazing job!"
"So glad we could help!! Thanks for your trust in us :)"
Gunes Ozyurt
September 16, 2025
"Mike McNicholas and his staff of professionals are a Great group to work with. Brett Callarmen helped me finalize adding a new auto and other policy changes for family and handled the process very efficiently. Brett worked with me to make sure I got the coverage I needed at a reasonable cost. I highly recommend this State Farm agency and Brett for your Insurance needs."
"Thank you Gunes! you have been part of our history for a long time and we are very grateful"
Caryn Hall
September 15, 2025
"Brett got me a great deal on car insurance."
"Thanks Caryn, welcome to our agency!!"
James Birdsell
September 15, 2025
"Appreciated all the help and explanation of the insurance"
" : )"